Chondrosarcoma of the hyoid bone: a case of mistaken identity in the submandibular region
- 1 Department of Undergraduate Medical Education, University of Nottingham, Nottingham, UK
- 2 Department of Otolaryngology, Lincoln County Hospital, Lincoln, UK
- Correspondence to Dr Emma Burman Turner; emmat@chenga.com
Abstract
We describe a case of woman in her 60s who presented with a painless mass in her left submandibular region that biopsies and imaging suggested was a pleomorphic adenoma. Intraoperative findings showed a submandibular mass originating from the hyoid bone, and subsequent histopathological examination showed a grade 2 chondrosarcoma of the hyoid bone. Chondrosarcomas in the head and neck region are uncommon and presentations in the hyoid bone are very rare with only approximately 27 previously published cases. Presentations that pose as more benign pathology can cause diagnostic dilemmas for clinicians.
Background
The hyoid bone is an unusual site for a chondrosarcoma. A review of PubMed (Medline) revealed 27 published cases in English-language literature with further unpublished reports dating back as far as 1919.1 Chondrosarcomas of the hyoid bone present a diagnostic challenge, given the range of differentials in the submandibular region and the slow-growing nature of chondrosarcomas, clinicians can often assume a more common and benign aetiology. Cytological diagnosis of the lesion cannot always be relied upon as a review of the literature shows multiple reports of false negative or non-diagnostic fine-needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) samples.2–7 Imaging can be a more reliable method of diagnosis with chondrosarcomas often exhibiting characteristic calcified matrixes on CT, although this can easily be missed on initial investigations such as ultrasound. Definitive diagnosis and treatment is wide local excision with histopathological study of the specimen. Negative tumour margins and differentiation of the specimen are vital for a more positive prognosis. In this case, we present a case of chondrosarcoma of the hyoid bone that was initially diagnosed as pleomorphic adenoma before histological analysis post-wide local excision.
Case presentation
A woman in her 60s presented in 2021 via a 2-week wait referral pathway with a slowly enlarging painless mass in the left submandibular region with associated mild hoarseness of voice. Her community records show that she first presented with this mass back in 2018 and was investigated with ultrasound, which was normal, and she was subsequently discharged from the otolaryngology clinic. After representing in 2021, a MRI of the neck was suggestive of a branchial cyst or cystic hygroma but subsequent FNAC was in keeping with pleomorphic adenoma. During submandibular gland excision, a normal-appearing submandibular gland was dissected anteriorly from the anterior belly of digastric muscle with a multiloculated mass visualised at the inferior aspect of the gland that clinically appeared to arise from the hyoid bone. This mass extended into the parapharyngeal space with adherence to the digastric tendon; the posterior belly of digastric was removed with partial excision of the hyoid bone. Histology of the excisional biopsy showed an unremarkable left submandibular gland. The mass attached to the hyoid bone was a fragmented multinodular lesion in keeping with a grade 2 chondrosarcoma. This patient was treated with surgical excision with negative tumour margins. Adjuvant radiotherapy is being considered following sarcoma multidisciplinary team (MDT) discussion to reduce risk of recurrence. Follow-up imaging done in 2022 shows no evidence of recurrence.
Investigations
An ultrasound-guided aspiration of the neck in 2021 showed a lobulated mass measuring 3.8×3.4 cm closely related to the inferior aspect of the left submandibular gland. No vascularity was detected and it was of unclear aetiology. An FNAC of this mass was in keeping with a pleomorphic adenoma.
An MRI of the neck with contrast in 2021 showed a predominately septated cystic lesion measuring approximately 4.2×2.6 cm medial to the left submandibular gland and extending into the left parapharyngeal space. It abutted the base of the tongue. The submandibular gland was described as normal. The potential diagnosis was branchial cyst or cystic hygroma. No relationship to the hyoid bone was described (see figure 1A,B and figure 2A,B).
(A,B) Sagittal view of chondrosarcoma of the hyoid on T1-weighted MRI with contrast shows a septated cystic lesion (white arrow—dashed) measuring approximately 42×26 mm medial to the left submandibular gland (white arrow) and abutting the base of the tongue. There is evidence of slight mass effect to the pharyngeal airway (red arrow).

(A,B) Axial view of chondrosarcoma of the hyoid on T1-weighted (figure 3) and T2-weighted (figure 4) MRI with contrast showing the septated lesion. Note in figure 4 the high signal intensity in comparison with the left.

Postoperatively a CT of the neck, chest, abdomen and pelvis with contrast was performed for staging purposes. This showed soft tissue swelling and irregular margins on the left of the hyoid bone, measuring 2.4×1.7 cm likely secondary to postoperative changes (see figure 3).
Axial view of the neck on a CT with contrast at the hyoid level one month postoperatively. There is soft tissue swelling with irregular margins of the left side of the hyoid bone (arrow).

A follow-up MRI of the neck with contrast in 2022 showed that the likely postoperative changes described previously had since settled. Asymmetrical enhancement of the right hemi-tongue was described in keeping with likely hypoglossal paresis (see figure 4).
Axial view of the neck on a T1-weighted MRI with contrast at the hyoid level 1 month postoperatively. There is a focally ill-defined lesion seen in the left submandibular region, which is likely post-surgical changes (arrow).

Differential diagnosis
Solid primary lesions of the hyoid bone are very uncommon with chondrosarcomas of the hyoid being a rarer presentation. Other differentials for solid primary lesions of the hyoid bone include osteosarcoma,8 giant cell tumour,9 plasmacytomas,10 osteoblastomas11 and aneurysmal bone cysts.12
Osteosarcomas are the other most common type of bony/cartilaginous malignant tumours typically affecting those in adolescence, whereas chondrosarcomas affect those most commonly in the fourth to fifth decade of their life.13 Radiographically, both can show evidence of bony destruction.
Differentials for a mass in the submandibular region beyond solid primary lesions are wide. A review of 66 subjects presenting with surgical intervention for submandibular masses showed the most common mass (39.3%) being a tumour, although the vast majority (77%) were benign most commonly in the form of pleomorphic adenomas. Following this, the most common was sialadenitis (27.2%) and then lymphadenitis (15.1%). The most common presenting symptom was that of a painless mass, which is how our patient, like most hyoid chondrosarcomas, presented.14
Outcome and follow-up
This patient had a successful excision and is being followed up by the specialist chondrosarcoma MDT in the region. She reports no new symptoms or issues.
Discussion
Chondrosarcomas are malignant cartilaginous tumours that often present as slow-growing masses most commonly seen in the pelvis, proximal femur, proximal humerus and ribs.15 They are the second most common sarcoma arising from the bone but are not commonly seen in the head and neck region, accounting for only 1%–12% of reported cases. When they do present, they tend to be more commonly seen in the skull base, larynx or maxilla.15
In the head and neck region, chondrosarcomas present as slow-growing, painless masses over the anterior or lateral aspect of the neck. The more insidious nature of growth, alongside lack of other concerning features, can falsely mimic benign pathology and delay presentation or diagnosis, with some cases reporting up to 7 years of growth before presentation.16
Chondrosarcomas tend to present in the fourth to fifth decade of life, although literature describes presentations from 30 to 88 years of age.17 18 Chondrosarcomas have been reported to show a slight male predominance of 1.9:113; however, other reports suggest there is no predominance to either gender.19
Due to the lack of radiation exposure, ultrasound is often used as the first method of investigation. This is an unreliable diagnostic investigation for chondrosarcomas given the lack of detail appreciable and ability to detect calcifications on the scan. In our case, the first ultrasound in 2018 demonstrated no abnormalities despite the symptom of a mass, while the second ultrasound describes the lesion being of unknown aetiology.
Literature describes CT as being the gold-standard imaging of choice for chondrosarcomas often revealing a heterogeneous expansive mass with matrix calcification and, in some cases, destruction of the hyoid bone itself.4 In our case, MRI was done preoperatively and did not describe the features typical of a chondrosarcoma.
MRI provides no further aid in characterisation of the tumour but provides a benefit in preoperative surgical planning given its multiplanar capabilities.20 Typically on MRI, chondrosarcomas show low signal intensity in T1-weighted imaging and high signal intensity in T2.2 21 It can provide benefit over CT in its increased sensitivity to detecting necrosis seen in higher-grade lesions.22
Biopsies make up an important part of the diagnostic approach to lesions. In many cases, the cytological samples were reported as false negatives or inconclusive.2–7 This can be attributed to the small nature of the target site, performing the biopsy without radiographical guidance or aspirating a sample that does not contain atypical cells. In this case, the cytology showed myxoid stoma with rounded cells; in combination with a reassuring MRI of the neck, the diagnosis was that of a more common pleomorphic adenoma. This case shows the limitations of FNAC not aspirating atypical cells, particularly in rarer conditions. The diagnosis of grade 2 chondrosarcoma relied on histological examination of the excisional biopsy.
Histopathological characteristics of chondrosarcomas include increased cellularity, nuclear atypia and hyperchromasia. These characteristics can determine the grade of the specimen.23 Grading of the chondrosarcoma is important for treatment, prognosis and metastatic potential. Differentiating these lesions from normal or benign tissue depends on recognition of the tumour invading the marrow cavity of the bone.
-
Grade 1 chondrosarcomas make up the majority of reported chondrosarcomas of the hyoid bone and are only locally aggressive. These tumours closely resemble normal cartilage with some atypical cells.
-
Grade 2 lesions contain more atypical cells exhibiting hyperchromasia and binucleated or multinucleated cells. There have been, to the best of our knowledge, seven previous cases of grade 2 chondrosarcoma.
-
Grade 3 lesions show hypercellularity with a sparse matrix. Cells are larger and more often multinucleated as they have become further differentiated. Necrosis can sometimes be seen.
The treatment of choice in chondrosarcomas is wide local excision, ensuring negative tumour margins, given the high recurrence rate of these lesions. One paper suggests that in the case of grade 1 chondrosarcomas, careful curettage alone can be used to treat the lesion.24 Given that the rate of recurrence for chondrosarcomas in the head and neck region is higher than the rest of the body, wide local excision would be preferable to most surgeons.25
There have been cases where radiotherapy has been used in the treatment of chondrosarcomas, although chondrosarcomas are relatively radio insensitive. Radiotherapy can play a part in cases where patients do not wish to have surgery or where the lesion is inaccessible, for example, extending into the skull base.7 It has been described as an adjunctive to wide local excision in several cases, in both grade 1 and grade 2 chondrosarcomas, although the indication for this is unclear.20 In this case, with negative tumour margins, follow-up is sufficient, and MRI would be suitable given its specificity in soft issue pathology and non-ionising nature. This can be performed 6 month postoperatively and then as required, symptom dependent.
In one case, photodynamic therapy was used in a patient declining surgical intervention. While initial postprocedural therapy suggested tumour shrinkage, further follow-up imaging showed subsequent growth in the tumour size for which the patient underwent a further round of therapy. There is no further follow-up on this patient published.26
Prognosis is dependent on tumour grade with an analysis of chondrosarcomas throughout the whole body showed 5-year survival rate of 90% for grade 1, 81% for grade 2 and 29% for grade 3. The most common sites of metastases for chondrosarcomas are the lungs and distal bone.
An important factor is the presence of negative tumour margins post-excision; 83% of patients with negative tumour margins had no recurrence in comparison with 0% in patients with positive tumour margins.26 In light of this, patients should be taken for re-excision if positive tumour margins are reported. Patients should also have long-term follow-up given reports of recurrence several years after primary excision.22
Conclusion
Chondrosarcomas of the hyoid bone present as slow-growing, painless masses on the lateral and anterior neck and can commonly be mistaken for benign pathology. CT is the imaging modality of choice with MRI being used for planning of the surgical approach. This should be used in careful combination with cytological studies. Wide local excision is the treatment of choice with a lower grade and negative surgical margins being important factors for a more positive prognosis. Chondrosarcomas are radio insensitive and so this should be used in inaccessible tumours or patients declining surgical intervention. Given the high rate of recurrence, long-term follow-up is recommended.
Patient's perspective
I first noticed a change in the lump to the left side of my neck some six months ago before being seen but I had originally noticed a swelling under my jaw in 2018. It wasn’t painful or tender. I didn’t have difficulty swallowing or a sore throat, but I did have a hoarse voice for the last three months.
Learning points
-
Clinicians should be aware that primary hyoid lesions, including chondrosarcomas, can present as a submandibular mass.
-
CT is the initial imaging of choice due to its sensitivity of detecting calcifications; MRI is more useful for planning surgical approach.
-
Definitive treatment is with excision with negative tumour margins; radiotherapy can be used in cases where the patient declines surgery or where the lesion is inaccessible.
-
Follow-up is vital for these patients given the rate of recurrence; patients with positive surgical margins should undergo surgical revision.
Ethics statements
Patient consent for publication
Footnotes
-
Contributors The following author was responsible for drafting of the text, sourcing and editing of clinical images, investigation results, drawing original diagrams and algorithms, and critical revision for important intellectual content—EBT. The following authors gave final approval of the manuscript—EBT, RT and LT.
-
Funding The authors have not declared a specific grant for this research from any funding agency in the public, commercial or not-for-profit sectors.
-
Case reports provide a valuable learning resource for the scientific community and can indicate areas of interest for future research. They should not be used in isolation to guide treatment choices or public health policy.
-
Competing interests None declared.
-
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
- © BMJ Publishing Group Limited 2023. No commercial re-use. See rights and permissions. Published by BMJ.
References
Use of this content is subject to our disclaimer